On Hilaire Belloc: Fumbling in the Footsteps of a Giant

Hilaire Belloc by Eric Gill
Hilaire Belloc as drawn by Eric Gill

We need to more properly introduce Hilaire Belloc (1870-1953) at this website – that is, say more than we did recently here – given that we will be speaking so much more about him.

Accordingly, I offer a little further introduction below (while I also prepare to write a forthcoming, longer introduction to his profoundly Catholic life and thinking). But before that further introduction below, I note something regarding Belloc and this website.

First, I will say that discovering Belloc has been a profoundly joyous, yet also eerie experience for me. It is joyous, inasmuch as I have discovered a very dear friend, a life-long friend I think, even if my new dear friend died in 1953.

My First Video on Beloved Belloc—Article Continues Below

But it is eerie, inasmuch as I see parallels, which are somewhat unsettling to me.

They are parallels between my own writing and what Belloc said many years before me.

For I see now that what I am trying to say—here at this website and in my upcoming book—Belloc has often already said, but far better than I could do.

Or to put it another way: it is like finding out that in my own fumbling way, I have been walking in the footsteps of a giant who preceded me …

And yet a giant whose footsteps I never really recognised before—although I had read and acknowledged Belloc a little (as for example, his thoughts on Ireland here).

For this reason, we will soon feature extracts from Belloc, which correspond to particular themes at this website.

I hope that regular readers will recognise these themes. But perhaps it is useful, if I indicate a few of these now, giving a foretaste of what is to come…

For example, Belloc evidently felt the need, the burning need, to illustrate how imprisoned we are by the ‘Modern Mind’ (as he called it).

I cannot help but feel that same burning need and have been trying to say, how very provincial that modern mind is.

For example in a weblog entry (here), I indicated how provincial that modern mind is, in terms of both space and time.

There I spoke of:

The very significant divide between our contemporary “Americanised” world and that of Catholic France over a century ago [and how] struck [I am] by the sense of limitation, not only in space but also in time.

In space, I am referring of course to a certain cultural geography – one of Anglophone, secular and Protestant heritage.

But what of provincialism in time?

Here I confess a known friend of mine rises in my awareness.

Known friend: How you strike me as acutely reflective and moral! You were born in 1970, friend and forgive me, if I should offend.

But how profoundly it seems to me that your assumptions can be shaped by four decades of mainstream British culture bracketed: 1970 – 2010.

Like so many others, your harried, hectic life will not easily permit the reading of history and your media does little or nothing to compensate.

Known Friend – I address you in these pages and I do not think that you will object.

For you stand for countless others, including many unseen friends, who are also filled with heartfelt idealism.

Friends seen and unseen, I see your horror of the world, your sincere longing to find solutions, and I see your despair.

How I want to cry out loud: do not allow yourself to bracketed by a narrow slice of culture in time and space!

Do not let yourself be limited to Anglophone assumptions, circa 1970-2010. For otherwise there may be nothing left to do, but despair indeed.

Great Belloc Books to Begin With

For Belloc was not only very concerned by provincialism in time, but also by the provincialism of ‘Little England’. Yes, here is something from my own pen that aims at exactly what Belloc (I now see) was doing far better than me, decades ago.

Belloc had been raised in England, but he was of French birth and had a French father.

Continuously his mind saw beyond ‘Little England’ to France, and indeed to Europe and Christendom as a whole.

Indeed, his writing features a powerful vision invoking the Soul of Europe, the Soul of Christendom (sundered).

Fumbling, I grope my way towards the same vision.

For although I am not French (save for just a little French blood) my life has been changed forever by the short time (less than three years) that I lived and travelled in France.

This website owes a tremendous debt to not only France, but also Spain and Ireland —three countries of once-Catholic Europe.

Through living in these lands of Catholic heritage – by the Grace of God! – many of my own Anglo-American prejudices were burst wide-open.

Anglo-American, I say, because, as I have said before, I am an Englishman from California. (I was born in Los Angeles—but both my parents were British.)

And as a teenager, I came to live in my parents’ home country.

Autobiographical Video about These Very Things—Post Continues Below

Thus I came to see first-hand, both cultures which have dominated the modern world and the modern mind: what was once the British Empire and the present American Empire …

And I see now how trapped I was, for years, in the assumptions of those cultures, steeped as they are in Protestant and Secular conjectures.

Belloc had a great deal to say, a very great deal about the Protestant and Secular assumptions of the ‘Little England’ in which he lived.

It earned him many enemies.

I write this weblog, sadly realising that I will be acquiring enemies as well.

I write this weblog, preparing a book that I know will be very controversial.

It is controversial for the challenge it tries to mount towards our so-provincial Zeitgeist, which is, in so many ways, an English Zeitgeist …

For as the English language proceeds to dominate the world, it inevitably carries with it Anglo-American literature, Anglo-American thinking, Anglo-American attitudes along with it …

O Hilaire Belloc!

It seems to me that we need your powerful vision, now more than ever!

Thus in upcoming entries, we will feature extracts from Belloc’s thought about these things above …

But I must say the above represents only a small slice of Belloc’s thought.

I have emphasised some few things, where my own thinking parallels his, in ways, which, yes, I find a little eerie. But there is so much more to Belloc than this. I am reeling at the sheer breadth of his vision.

We will not detail this vision, at least not here, not yet . . .

More Key Belloc Books

Hilaire Belloc in Bullet Points

The faith of Hilaire Belloc.

However, let us offer some Bullet-Points that may indicate a little more the thinking of this great man.

Belloc’s vision elaborated on:

  • The Crisis of the materialistic Modern World
  • That Crisis being rooted in Plutocratic Capitalism and the reaction to Plutocratic Capitalism
  • That reaction being Socialism and Communism
  • The roots of Capitalism in Protestantism and Calvinism, usury and unrestricted competition following the Reformation
  • The Reformation as an immense and tragic catastrophe, sundering the Soul of Europe, of Christendom
  • Thus, the creation of a tyrannical, modern, abstract world divorced from the land, increasingly divorced from tradition, divorced from human ties and local affections
  • The arrogance, the sheer arrogance of the modern world view, powered by mindless reiteration through the media and advertising
  • The need for healing all of this, through an uncompromising return to the Catholic Faith, which lay at the centre of Christendom
  • The need for this to be complemented by Distributism – a third way beyond Capitalism and Socialism, which aimed for the wide distribution of property and the breaking down of large concentrations of wealth and power in the banks, corporations and so forth

And Belloc can hardly be limited to this! We have for example said nothing of his historical work, his poetry, his travel-writing about Catholic Europe etc.

But we must start somewhere.

And soon, very soon, we shall continue plunging into Belloc …

Distributism and Social Justice

Update 2023: Continued Eerie Joy

It is now eleven years since I posted this piece about my joy in discovering the great Belloc. And how that joy has deepened, year upon year, as I have drunk ever more deeply from that this master’s life-work.

In these last years, I have also had three books published by Angelico Press, which owe much to this brilliant soul, who has become like a cherished mentor for me. Advertisements for those three books are below—as well as for a fourth book by Belloc himself, which I have written an extensive (forty page!) foreword for:

Click to See at Amazon—Or Continue Article Below
Books from Roger Buck

Foreword for Monarchy by Roger Buck

But re-reading the piece above after many years, I am also reminded of simply the joy, but the eeriness, too . . .

For I re-call just how powerfully Belloc HIT me, like almost nothing else in my life and how well he articulated the very things I was struggling to articulate.

Now, recently, this came home even more strongly. For I re-discovered long forgotten video footage shot in Switzerland 2008, long before my life-changing encounter with Belloc and in this video footage I am expressing profoundly Bellocian things.

‘Expressing profoundly Bellocian things’ . . . it is more than just that!

What I say in that forgotten footage made me gasp. I was not only shocked, but I think I saw something of the meaning of my entire life-trajectory, from England and America, to France and Ireland . . .

But I will not say more here, as I have incorporated that personally astonishing footage into a video on our YouTube channel.

Not only does that video speak for itself, it is my personal favourite now on the entire channel. Here it is:

Books from Roger Buck

Foreword for Monarchy by Roger Buck


Buying Books at Amazon Through These Links Gives Us a Commission. This Supports Our Apostolate. Thank You if You Can Help Us Like This!

Related posts


comments are currently closed

13 responses to “On Hilaire Belloc: Fumbling in the Footsteps of a Giant”

  1. lowest current Avatar

    Mortgage interest were combined today as outlays enrolled gains after an
    early drop (

    1. roger Avatar

      Hello lowest current!

      Interesting name you have …

      Thank you for providing us with an example of just the kind of stuff Hilaire Belloc felt so deeply wounded by, that Hilaire Belloc dedicated his life to fighting …

      And to any reader who finds this little comment …

      I should like to say I get dozens of these spams which of course I never print.

      Many of them are hideously insincere.

      Like: “Awesome blog! Love your writing. Bookmarked your site and will come back all the time. You are fantastic! By the way, would you like a loan ….”

      I would say that Hilaire Belloc would be turning in his grave – except that I wonder if he is looking down from heaven with a weeping heart …

  2. […] Cor Jesu Sacratissimum HomeAbout UsKim's WeblogRoger's WeblogWebburstsReviewsImagoArticlesUK StoreUS Store « On Hilaire Belloc: Fumbling in the Footsteps of a Giant […]

  3. […] Recently at this weblog, we have tried to convey the thinking of Hilaire Belloc –  first looking at his critique of the Modern Mind, before we proceeding to other areas of his thought, including those regarding Capitalism, Distributism and his vision of Europe … […]

  4. […] I say this for reasons I indicate in so many places at this website – but perhaps of the numerous entries regarding Belloc at this site, it might be best to start here. […]

  5. roger Avatar

    Thank you, Charlotte – I had this spam in masses long, long, long before I reluctantly placed these adverts here.

    So I am not sure what the difference is – but again, thank you.

    I have not forgotten your other comments and you should have more substantial responses to your very important and intelligent concerns within the next 24 hours – possibly by the end of the day.

  6. Comment Deleted Avatar
    Comment Deleted

    This comment has been deleted at the author’s request.

  7. […] this I would say – along with Hilaire Belloc – includes our current plutocratic capitalist tyranny, which is now leading us to ecological […]

  8. […] At least, such is the considered view of figures as wildly and radically opposed as Rudolf Steiner and Hilaire Belloc. […]

  9. […] in the weeks ahead, as we continue to unpack Hilaire Belloc’s diagnosis of the modern world, we may become still […]

  10. […] And here from 1891 is Rerum Novarum – the beginning of the Church’s challenge to Plutocratic Capitalism (and a major inspiration for Hilaire Belloc, who we esteem at this website). […]

  11. […] Fumbling and bumbling as we are, we must try to take up what we can of that mission. As I said in my first major post about Hilaire Belloc, fumbling in the footsteps of a giant. […]

  12. […] I wrote about Hilaire Belloc’s footsteps before, in the summer of 2012 (some years after this site began in […]

  13. […] Indeed, I cannot help but feel I am following – or rather fumbling and bumbling – in the footsteps of Triumph. (Just as I once wrote (here) that I am also fumbling in the footsteps of Hilaire Belloc.) […]