Becoming a Clone: The Danger of Liberal Catholicism


Liverpool’s Catholic Cathedral –  a clear break from tradition and built in the 1960s. Photo courtesy of john driscoll [CC-BY-SA-2.0 (], via Wikimedia Commons

For today, just another short extract from my upcoming book – regarding one of the chief concerns of this website:

The attitude became prevalent during the 1960s that the ‘problem’ with the Catholic Church was that it was too closed-off or even hostile to modernity in all its tolerance, diversity and pluralism.

It was held that the Church had developed a ‘fortress mentality’ in recent centuries: like a castle under siege against the bounding waves of reformation and revolution. Many claimed it was high-time to recognise that modernity had been right all along in its enlightened, upbeat and liberal regard to humanity.

And it was maintained that all was needed was greater optimism, freedom and trust that people could find their own way now – if only they could be set free from ‘unnecessary legalism’.

Thus, many deemed it necessary that the Church abrogate its antiquated ‘medieval prattle’ regarding such ‘unedifying matters’ as Original Sin, Satan and the frightening reality of hell.

Yes, such attitudes became prominent nearly everywhere in the 1960s.

 Any sale via this link helps this site 

And Father Malachi Martin is right: a ‘strange euphoria’ seemed to grip the Church at that time – as indeed it did everywhere else during the epoch.

And when people are gripped by wild optimism about human nature – that is, by denial of the Fall – certain consequences naturally follow.

For such people see little danger in liberal emancipation from ‘useless’ old conventions, laws and taboos. Because those conventions, laws and taboos were forged in an altogether different context from bright, Enlightenment optimism.

This is to say, they were forged in a world which still comprehended Original Sin and the dark, fallen nature of the human heart.

And a world which still apprehends Original Sin is a world which can still appreciate the need for the safeguards provided by the wisdom of tradition. But liberal euphoria no longer comprehends such things at all.

Yes, excessive optimism is key to understanding the 1960s reforms – and excessive arrogance, as well.

Because for two thousand years, Christian saints and geniuses beheld Original Sin working in the dark recesses of the human heart. They recognised that Satan and legions of evil were at work in the world. They recognised temptation.

From all this, Christian tradition forged effective guardrails, preventatives and warnings.

But then came ‘the spring of 1968’ and people ‘knew better’ now.

And ‘knowing better’, they no longer required ‘outmoded, antediluvian’ safeguards like frequent Mass and confession of sin. They no longer needed to be warned about perdition. They no longer needed the manifold Catholic prayers and devotions which preserved the human heart against corruption.

And so it became ‘obligatory’ to abandon not only the ‘outdated’ traditional mentality of sin – but also to eradicate that ‘seige’ mentality, which had long separated the Church from the world.

At least, many people took Bl. John XXIII’s aggiornamento – Italian meaning literally ‘bringing up to date’ – to indicate such a course.

What this meant in practice was that the Church should be rather less like Herself and rather more like the other modern institutions.

This attitude was, for example, clearly noticeable in regard to Protestantism. For example, bitter conflict raged in the Council around the matter of the Blessed Virgin. Karl Rahner led something of a crusade against traditional emphasis of Our Lady at the Council – for the very reason that such emphasis would prove unpopular with Protestants.

And so from the Council onwards, devotion to Our Lady has been frequently scorned for reasons of ‘ecumenical sensitivity.’ And Rahner’s initiative was only the beginning of numerous similar impulses that followed in the years to come.

However, this is but a single instance of how the Sixties’ Catholic Church ‘protestantised’ Herself in order to diminish the gap between the reformed denominations and Her own tradition. When the new Mass was devised, very obvious Protestant additions and concessions were inserted in the Mass.

For example, the doxology ‘For Thine is the Kingdom, the Power and the Glory’ was added to the Pater Noster, following the Anglicans. And clearly, the new orientation of the Priest facing the people and speaking in the vernacular was far closer to an Anglican service than it was to the Catholic practice of centuries.

It is not without reason, then, that Joseph Ratzinger, the man who became Benedict XVI, has expressed concern, lest the Catholic Church become a clone of Protestantism.

But it is not only in regards to Protestantism that liberal Catholicism has aspired to become a clone.

Clearly, there has been a great liberal ambition that the Church further clone the likes of secular institutions as well: more democratic, more decentralised, more popularist and decidedly less hierarchical.

Hans Küng has even opined, for example, that the Church might emulate England’s so-called ‘glorious revolution’ of 1688 whereby the (Catholic) king of England, James II, was deposed in favour of parliamentary democracy and an anti-Catholic constitutional monarch. Küng has indicated that thereby the Pope might be retained as a mere figurehead in the Church, the way the English monarch is a figurehead today.

Not everyone is as radical as Küng – although many are (whether they say so openly or not).

Still, a clear ambition is at work in the world to remake the Church into yet another manifestation of Secular Materialism.

This entry was posted in Roger's Weblog and tagged . Bookmark the permalink. Post a comment or leave a trackback: Trackback URL.


  1. Posted 13 May 2013 at 12:12 | Permalink

    Dear Roger,

    Wonderful post, I fully agree with you, except in one point: the doxology. As far as I know the doxology is truly traditional, it’s use is recorded in the primitive church from the Second Century and it appears in many Catholic Bible translations as part of the Pater. The Orthodox Church also makes extensive use of the doxology.

    As always, magnificent post and blog!

    Blessings in Christ and Mary.

  2. Posted 15 May 2013 at 18:17 | Permalink

    Juan – thank you. I see how my wording above could be misleading and will change it – at least slightly. I was aware that the doxology was indeed ancient. My point was not to suggest that it was of Protestant or Anglican inspiration – only that it was added to the New Mass in the effort to meet Protestants who used it commonly.

    I must have a think. For the words, as I intended them, are not inaccurate, but I have obviously given you and maybe others the wrong impression. Thank you for correcting my sloppiness! (Especially in something going into my book!)

2 Trackbacks

  1. […] is why I write, dear Reader, in severe terms of the danger of liberal Catholicism becoming a clone of Protestantism. Here is why I write about the terrible cost of Zany Catholicism […]

  2. […] the man who is now our Holy Father also warns against the Catholic Church becoming a CLONE of Protestantism […]

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>


  • Books from Roger Buck

    Foreword by Roger Buck

  • The Gentle Traditionalist Returns!

    New Book from Angelico Press!

    "The Gentle Traditionalist returns with a vengeance in this stand-alone sequel ... this book skewers the modern malaise with the kind of sanity we have come to expect from this author” — CHARLES A. COULOMBE

    ”Buck’s latest foray is a grand success ... The story features the same singular combination of whimsy and surprise, keen social commentary, and deft argumentation as the first [book]. The Gentle Traditionalist Returns appeals to what is best and deepest in us, so that we will reengage with that which ultimately matters while there is yet time.” — PETER KWASNIEWSKI

    ”A brilliant diagnosis of the spiritual malaise of modern society, written with gentleness, generosity, humour, pathos ... and, above all else, love”— MAOLSHEACHLANN Ó CEALLAIGH

    buy-at-amazon Video about New Book here:

  • Books from Roger Buck


    The Gentle Traditionalist


    ”Roger Buck ... in the spirit of Chesterton and Belloc ... takes on everything—from the reforms of Vatican II to the New Age ... a wonderful book.”— MICHAEL MARTIN

    ”A tale of whimsical fantasy, melancholy realism, and supernatural joy ... Buck’s deftly-reasoned post-modern apologetic for full-blooded Catholicism—a Syllabus of Errors in narrative form, a rousing hymn to ‘meaning, grace, beauty, life’.” — PETER KWASNIEWSKI

    "As brilliant a guide for the perplexed as this age is capable of producing” — CHARLES A. COULOMBE


    See Reviews in Full Here!


    Read First Chapter Online Here!


    Cor Jesu Sacratissimum



    ”Buck goes to the heart of the problem paralyzing our broken-hearted world ... moving beyond the spirit of the age to the Spirit who moves all ages.” — JOSEPH PEARCE

    ”In this elegant feast of a book, Roger Buck ... expertly skewers the modern world ... without a drop of malice in his compassionate soul ... to reveal the bright, shining love and truth at the center of the universe—symbolised by the Sacred Heart of Jesus, and incarnate in the Catholic Church.” — CHARLES A. COULOMBE

    ”A great service to the Church ... Buck shows that the New Age is an attempt, however flawed, to escape the materialism of modernity, and that it is Catholicism in its traditional forms that can best reveal the immense reality of the suffering and love for all mankind of Christ’s Sacred Heart.”— JOSEPH SHAW


    See Reviews in Full Here!


  • EWTN Interview with Roger Buck here!

    TWO-part “Celtic Connections” EWTN  Interview!

    Part One here.

    Part Two here.

  • First Video from Kim Buck!